Dexo Design

Russell Wilson
is the principal of Dexo Design
and the Vice President of Product
Design at NetQoS in Austin, Texas
Email: russ ...[click here]... @dexodesign.com

Usability News

ARTICLES

(subscribe)

Can you name which design or usability principles this violates?

Bad Door Sign

The bottom line is a series of arrows pointing to the left door.
(apologies for the poor quality photograph)

12 Responses to “ Can you name which design or usability principles this violates? ”

  1. Tom Kiss says:

    It’s a door. People know to use doors.
    Normally, you say what not to use, surely…

    (Don’t call me Shirley)

  2. Hrvoje says:

    Which door? Left or right? Maybe we should read that small print on the bottom.

  3. Ray Maz says:

    The text says “this” door when it really means “that” door, i.e. the arrows indicate the the door to the left of the sign should be used. The sign is misleading, because the most important information (the arrows pointing left) is not appropriately noticeable

  4. Allan says:

    DRY (Don’t Repeat Yourself)

    Ok, it’s somewhat a stretch, but works for me.

  5. peter says:

    Accessibility. No audio or braille version for blind users.

  6. I apologize for the quality of the picture. The line at the bottom is actually a series of arrows pointing to the left door. The sign is saying “don’t use this door (the one to the left)”

  7. Paul Keeble says:

    A possible GUI analogy of this would be a label saying “OK >>>” and then having a button with no text on it which was meant to be clicked.

    Another possibility is rather than greying out a button the button says “please use this button>>>>” pointing at the cancel.

    Its not a basic usability problem but a very strange way to achieve disabling a function by having disabled function point at the only remaining option.

  8. They shouldn’t be pointing at the door to use, they would be better off just putting the sign on the left door with no arrows.

    Plus, the arrows are really small compared to the type and they don’t catch the eye at all (assuredly they aren’t even visible in the distance) so people will probably just bump on the wrong door.

  9. Rob says:

    Poor affordance, the suggestion of how to interact with door is misleading.

  10. John Chin says:

    It’s like having a giant label over a button saying “click here”
    (sound familiar?)

    There are tons of signs that have terrible affordances.
    I was at an Ikea Store and the parking sign said
    “All Parking
    No Trucks”

    Go figure!

  11. Amanda Woo says:

    This violets the “support workflow” of the Nielsen Usability principle since the wording of the sign does coincide with the tiny arrows as indicated at the bottom of the sign. Basically, the wording contradicts the image.

  12. Great info.Very good article.Bookmarked your blog plz keep it up :)

Leave a Reply

©2003-2008 Russell Wilson. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Wordpress and hosted by (mt) Media Temple

Alltop, confirmation that we kick ass